What’s Voluntary and Involuntary Manslaughter?
5 months ago by Justin M. Schiks
Murder and manslaughter are different crimes. Murder is the intentional killing of a human being. Manslaughter does not involve the intent to kill. In Minnesota, a person can be charged with one of two types of manslaughter: involuntary or voluntary manslaughter
What is Involuntary Manslaughter in Minnesota?
Involuntary manslaughter is the criminal act of causing a victim’s death because of gross negligence or reckless behavior. This means the person being charged had a total disregard for other people’s safety. The death may have been accidental, but because the person acted with reckless disregard, they can be charged with involuntary manslaughter.
One type of involuntary manslaughter is vehicular homicide. Vehicular homicide occurs when a driver causes an accident that kills a victim or her unborn fetus because of total disregard for human life. For example, the driver was texting at the time of the accident or driving under the influence of alcohol.
A depraved heart is another type of involuntary manslaughter. In Minnesota, depraved heart murder is behavior so dangerous that the person would not have acted so badly if they didn’t have a depraved mind or heart. One example of this is the crime of walking into a crowd and shooting a gun in the air and killing someone. The person didn’t intend to kill anyone. However, they acted with a depraved heart because they wanted to see people fear for their lives.
The individual’s behavior doesn’t reflect a plan to harm, but it’s so careless that the law holds them accountable.
Common scenarios include:
- Driving under the influence and causing a deadly crash
- Ignoring safety violations on a property that lead to someone’s death
In Woodbury, Minnesota, these offenses fall under second-degree manslaughter. Minnesota law, specifically Section 609.205, outlines this charge and its legal standards.
Penalties for Second-Degree Manslaughter:
- Up to 10 years in prison
- Fines up to $20,000
Charges like these require a careful legal approach that considers the full scope of the behavior and its impact.
Get In Touch With Us
Examples of Involuntary Manslaughter
Involuntary manslaughter occurs when the accused party kills a person in a negligent manner. Also committed without premeditation, involuntary manslaughter is not done with any true intent to kill. However, fatality still occurs.
Vehicular Homicides
Involuntary manslaughter may also be listed under the category of vehicular homicide. This type of killing results when a defendant is negligent while driving, which leads to an accident. Two types of criminal vehicular homicides are tried in Minnesota – one for unborn fetuses and one for human beings.
A vehicular homicide charge addresses reckless driving, drunk driving, or texting while driving. Also known as manslaughter in the second degree, this form of involuntary manslaughter covers incidents where the guilty party’s carelessness created an unreasonable risk.
Legal Defenses in Involuntary Manslaughter Cases
Facing an involuntary manslaughter charge doesn’t mean the case is hopeless. Legal defenses may include proving the death was accidental but not caused by criminal negligence, or demonstrating the accused had no legal duty to act. In some cases, the defense may show that the actions were not directly responsible for the fatal outcome.
A tailored defense strategy focuses on challenging the prosecution’s evidence and narrative. In Woodbury, having a knowledgeable defense attorney can distinguish between a conviction and a reduced charge or dismissal.
What Is Voluntary Manslaughter in Minnesota?
Voluntary manslaughter is the criminal act of intentionally causing another human being’s death. This means a person is accused of doing something or not doing something to cause the victim to die. For example, voluntary manslaughter in Minnesota is called the heat of passion.
The heat of passion killing occurs when a person is provoked by a situation such as finding their spouse having sex with someone else. They kill the spouse. They were provoked by emotions and did not intend to cause their spouse harm. Thus, they would be charged with voluntary manslaughter instead of murder.
Another example of voluntary manslaughter is unintentionally causing a victim’s death by selling, administering, or giving away a controlled substance. The victim takes the controlled substance and dies. The person that sold or gave the victim the substance can be charged with voluntary manslaughter in Minnesota.
The person may believe they’re in danger or experience something so intense that it overrides self-control.
Imagine discovering a betrayal or being physically threatened during an argument; these circumstances may lead to this charge. While the killing is intentional, it’s not premeditated.
Under Minnesota Statutes Section 609.20, voluntary manslaughter includes killings that happen in the heat of passion, provided the provocation would cause an ordinary person to lose control.
Penalties for Voluntary Manslaughter in Woodbury, Minnesota:
- Prison time up to 15 years
- Fines as high as $30,000
An Example of Voluntary Manslaughter
Voluntary manslaughter happens when another person is killed without premeditation, malice, or deliberation. For example, this type of killing may occur in the heat of passion. While the offender did mean to kill or inflict bodily harm, they did not premeditate the homicide.
Voluntary manslaughter is usually referred to as second-degree murder. Second-degree murder is similar to first-degree murder but features certain mitigating circumstances. In this case, the offender may have been provoked or believed the killing was legally justified.
The Difference Between Involuntary Vs Voluntary Manslaughter In Minnesota
Understanding the legal distinction between involuntary vs voluntary manslaughter is vital if facing these charges in Woodbury, Minnesota. Though both are serious felonies, the key difference is whether the act was intentional.
Involuntary manslaughter applies when someone unintentionally causes another person’s death through reckless or grossly negligent behavior. There’s no intent to kill, only actions that show a disregard for life. Examples include fatal traffic accidents caused by distraction or situations where someone fails to correct a known hazard. Under Minnesota law, this is typically charged as second-degree manslaughter and carries a sentence of up to 10 years in prison and a $20,000 fine.
Voluntary manslaughter involves an intentional act of killing, but it occurs in the heat of the moment or under extreme emotional distress. A person might react to a serious provocation or threat and lose control. While the act is deliberate, the law accounts for the intensity of the situation, though the consequences remain severe, up to 15 years in prison and $30,000 in fines.
Murder in the First Degree
First-degree murder is the most severe and terrible type of homicide in Minnesota, as it is in other states. This subcategorization means that not all murders are treated as first-degree murders when charges are filed.
Aggravating circumstances are typically added to a case of a first-degree murder charge. The identification of the victim is usually the determining factor in cases that involve a first-degree murder charge.
This type of killing frequently involves the intentional death of a person in authority or a known family member. Victims may include a spouse or child following prolonged episodes of domestic violence, or a police officer, a judge, or a witness to a crime.
Murder in the First Degree can be prosecuted in cases involving sexual assault, burglary, aggravated robbery, abduction, arson, or terrorism. It may also be tried in cases involving a premeditated murder, when the offender contemplates, plots, or prepares for the killing beforehand.
If convicted of first-degree murder in Minnesota, the maximum sentence is life in prison without the possibility of parole. Again, intent to kill is required for the charge. It also requires calling a grand jury to review the case beforehand.
Murder in the Second Degree
While a second-degree murder may involve an intended killing, its penalty is less harsh than a first-degree murder conviction. When a person willfully murders another person, but the murder was not planned in advance, the crime might be classified as a second-degree murder instead.
Killing on the spur of the moment or as the result of a strong emotional reaction might amount to second-degree murder. In addition, a second-degree murder charge may be brought in the event of a drive-by shooting, the execution of a crime, other than sexual assault, or the accidental killing of a person against whom an order of protection was issued. If convicted of second-degree murder, an offender may face up to 40 years in jail.
Murder in the Third Degree
The motive for this murder was not to kill. An allegation of murder in the third degree is typically brought forth because of a “depraved heart.” This sort of crime can occur, for instance, when a person shoots a gun in a crowded area, but doesn’t mean to murder anybody specifically.
A person is guilty of third-degree murder if they distribute substandard drugs as well. Killing someone may get you up to 25 years in jail. A maximum fine of $40,000 may be imposed if the death was caused by the distribution of a Schedule I or II narcotic.
Murder Committed Willfully
If the defendant’s murder was precipitated by a severe emotional response, then voluntary manslaughter charges, rather than murder charges, may be brought against them. Again, a “crime of passion” is a common term for this situation.
The distribution of a Schedule III, IV, or V-restricted drug, which results in the death of another person, is another circumstance that might lead to this conviction.
Murder Without Provocation
Negligent homicide lies at the heart of the definition of involuntary manslaughter. This type of killing might happen if a hunter accidentally kills a person because they thought they were a game animal, such as a deer.
If a child dies because of negligence, the perpetrator might face involuntary manslaughter charges. This crime, as noted, is also the basis for charging a defendant with vehicular murder when the defendant’s careless driving leads to a fatality.
Differentiating Between Accidental and Intentional Killings
Again, an inadvertent or unintended killing constitutes involuntary manslaughter.
Murder committed intentionally, but out of passion or anger, is considered voluntary manslaughter. Some people use the term “provoked homicide” to describe this situation.
Factors That Can Influence Sentencing
Manslaughter sentencing isn’t one-size-fits-all. The court takes into account several key factors:
- The defendant’s criminal history
- The circumstances surrounding the act
- Whether the individual shows remorse
- Cooperation with law enforcement
Woodbury, Minnesota judges often weigh these aspects when determining a sentence. This is why legal representation that fully explores the human side of the case is so essential.
In either case, manslaughter charges are life-altering. A strong legal defense starts with understanding the circumstances and ensuring your story is fully heard in court.
Manslaughter Defenses
Possible justifications for not being found guilty of murder or manslaughter are case-specific. If the victim attacked the defendant and the defendant retaliated in kind to protect themselves, they may have a valid self-defense claim. If the accused did not commit the murder, then the defense of innocence applies.
Other defenses, such as drunkenness or self-defense but with excessive force, may not exonerate the offender entirely, but may lessen the severity of the charges against them.
Contact a Criminal Defense Lawyer Near You
Penalties for Manslaughter Crimes
The penalty for voluntary manslaughter is 15 years in prison. A person may have to pay a $30,000 fine. The penalty for involuntary manslaughter is 10 years in prison. The person may have to pay a $20,000 fine, too. The actual sentence depends on any priors and the circumstances of the case.
Contact JS Defense for Legal Assistance
A criminal charge of voluntary or involuntary manslaughter can result in serious penalties such as prison time. This is not a time to hope for the best and fear the worst. We understand the seriousness of criminal charges. We have helped numerous clients facing a manslaughter charge achieve outcomes in their favor at trial. If you or your loved one is being charged with a manslaughter crime near St-Paul or Woodbury, MN, contact us.
